Retired Court of Appeal Justice Oludotun Adefope Okojie has cautioned Nigerian courts against declaring candidates winners when the lawful votes do not establish that the electorate chose them. Delivering the 2026 Gavel International Annual Lecture in Ikeja, Lagos, she argued that the ballot box, not the courtroom, must remain the ultimate source of political authority.
She said that where irregularities make the voters’ true choice impossible to determine, the right remedy is a fresh election or rerun, not a judicial declaration of a winner. Courts, she added, should declare a candidate victorious only where lawful votes clearly establish the outcome. She urged courts to prefer substance over form, and called for rigorous integrity screening of election tribunal members.
Senior Advocate Femi Falana called for an overhaul of electoral litigation to stop election appeals from overwhelming the Supreme Court. He proposed restoring the earlier arrangement for governorship disputes, a reform that he said has stalled since 2011, and criticized past rulings in Kogi and Zamfara that he said displaced voters’ choices.